Better Visual Wordpress Posts Like to Share? Then Get The Shareaholics Plugin for Firefox
Sep 06

What is a Link Train? A link train is a list of links to other blogs in the form of a blog post “chain letter” where someone posts on their blog and then asks that other blogs copy that original list and add their own site at the bottom. Once you’ve copied the list and added your own link to the bottom, you would ask others to do the same. So what you end up with is a blog post that is essentially a long list of links to other blogs.
Why would someone do it? If you’ve been blogging for any time at all, it’s easy: lots of links, and possibly lots of traffic. Also the idea of raising their “authority” on Technorati and Google Page Rank is very appealing, although tthe truth seems to be that Google may consider such posts “link farms” and those who participate could be penalised, rather than benefiting from the scheme.

Ia of Blog Tutorials lists a few reasons why Link Trains can be appealing to bloggers, including the plain fact that they can be rewarding. He says “You are helping other bloggers and they help you.” True. He wisely goes on, I should point out, to note the downsides as well, including the biggie: “Link trains can even be considered as spam or even link farms-and can therefore be penalized by Google!”

If you want to read a truly compelling argument not to participate in Link Trains, read this insightful article by Andrew at alleba.com . When talking about Alexa Link Trains, he says “…it becomes viral because, who doesn’t want links? Every struggling blogger would jump at any chance to get links, right? That’s why it’s so easy to ask them to join. In the end, the originator gets all the link love while the rest are placed in a link farm.”

Another thought by swapw : “Not only does it abuse the blogosphere of its reputations of organic rankings, it’s just another way to cheat the system.”

Summary:

Spam works. We know this, because otherwise our inboxes wouldn’t be full of offers to enhance our sex lives and sell us prescription drugs “fer cheep”!

Link Trains are spam. They add nothing to the blog who posts them or its readers, and are simply a way to try to “cheat” your way to the top. And sadly, they are more beneficial to the person who starts them than to those who participate.

Effective? Possibly, although I can guarantee you that for every cheat method, google, alexa, and others have people working full time to figure out a way to stop it? Why, because when their results are skewed by cheating, it renders their product ineffective.

Last Thought:

By participating in Link Trains, you may actually hurt your reputation. In addition to losing out on Pagerank benefits and possibly being labled as a link-farm spammer, anyone who bothers to look will be put off when they see.

Example: I saw a highly “authoritative” blog on Technorati… something over 1000+. I went to her site, and it was nothing special. It looked like a million other newbie blogs, and it wasn’t that interesting. Why, I wondered, would so many hundreds upon hundreds of people be linking to her? I did a quick peek at her ‘authority’ and saw that it all came from link farms. Ugh. I felt cheated by this “fake” ranking.

Tempting? Yes. Worth it? No.

4 Responses to “Link Trains: Think Twice”

  1. PreBlogging Says:

    Nice post and summary about Link Trains, a topic that has been close to my heart this week ;) I’m glad I found your blog !

  2. Dana Wallert Says:

    I think it really depends on what your goals are. If you’re trying to build up “blog juice” just for profits sake, I suppose a blog full of links trains would be pretty common place. On the other hand, if you’re blogging to truly share and learn with a community, then I think you need to try and make all (well, at least most) posts valuable in one way or another to your readers and peers.

    All that being said, personally, I agree with you!

  3. PreBlogging Says:

    I have a lengthily discussion about Link Trains here. http://www.preblogging.com/blog-link-trains/

    Basically I was linked on one of these without my permission and I didn’t want to be associated with it, but still I find myself on one. So sometimes you don’t have so much control over these things,

    Becky (thanks the blogroll link :D)

  4. Linktrains - good or evil? » MarcoRichter.net Says:

    […] Link Trains: Think Twice […]

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the bitter security word shown in the picture.
Anti-spam image